Overall, U Me Aur Hum strikes the chord but not without its share of flaws. Devgan has proves to be good story teller with his debut direction. If not for anything, watch it for Kajol - great performance.
By
Ashok Nayak 
The biggest problem with Ajay Devgan's film is the sheer lack of consistency in tone, whether visual or emotional.
By
Jahan Bakshi 
Nothing that Ajay Devgan has done in the past prepares us for the poise, poignancy and sensitivity of his directorial debut. "U, Me Aur Hum" is one of those tender and tactile melodramas that leave you with minty thoughts and dewy eyes.
By
Subhash K Jha 